Contested. Speculative. Possibly heretical.

Is the Old World Actually Dead?

GW released The Old World as a game. The End Times supposedly destroyed everything. The theory that the Mortal Realms an

Is the Emperor of Mankind Actually Sigmar?

The theory that refuses to die: the God-Emperor of Mankind and the God-King of the Mortal Realms are the same being, sep

Is Omegon Still Alive?

Alpharius died at Pluto. Alpharius confirmed this. The Alpha Legion has two Primarchs and one of them is unaccounted for

Is Roboute Guilliman in Love with Yvraine?

Gathering Storm implied it. Black Library danced around it. The community has argued about it ever since. What the actua

How Many Space Marines Actually Exist?

Official answer: roughly one thousand Chapters of one thousand Marines each, making approximately one million Space Mari

Will Slaanesh Ever Be Fully Freed?

The missing god of excess is the most significant unresolved plot thread in Age of Sigmar. The aelves are using his powe

Which Primarchs Are Still Alive?

Official answer: Lion El'Jonson, Roboute Guilliman, possibly others. Actual answer: the community has compelling cases f

Is the Void Dragon Responsible for the Adeptus Mechanicus?

A C'tan Shard is imprisoned beneath Mars. The Adeptus Mechanicus worships a machine deity called the Omnissiah. These fa

Is Cypher Actually Loyal to the Emperor?

He carries a plasma pistol he never fires and a sword he never draws. He has been imprisoned in the Tower of Angels and

Is Lion El'Jonson Actually a Traitor?

He was at Zaramund. He was late to Signus Prime. He executed Luther's closest ally without explanation. The Dark Angels

Did Malcador Know About the Heresy Before It Happened?

He was the greatest psyker humanity has ever produced. The Emperor kept secrets from everyone except Malcador. The quest

Did Sanguinius Have to Die at Terra?

The Angel foresaw his death. He walked into the Vengeful Spirit knowing what waited for him. Some believe he chose it. S

Is Sigmar Planning to Betray Nagash?

They were allies. Nagash wanted all souls. Sigmar needed Nagash's power. The alliance ended badly. The theory is not whe

Is Chaos Actually Winning the Long War?

The Cicatrix Maledictum split the galaxy. Cadia fell. The Eye of Terror expanded. The Imperium is described as dying slo

Is Teclis Secretly Working Against Sigmar?

He created the Lumineth without telling Sigmar his methods. He destroyed the cursed cities to prevent Nagash taking them

Which Version of Night Haunter's Death Is Canon?

Konrad Curze died waiting for an assassin he could have stopped. Multiple sources describe what happened in that room. N

What Really Happened to the Two Missing Primarchs?

Two Primarchs were expunged from Imperial records before the Heresy. Their names have never been officially revealed. GW

Did the Age of Sigmar Retcon Destroy the Old World Lore?

When GW ended Warhammer Fantasy and launched Age of Sigmar in 2015, the community reaction was unlike anything before or

Did Horus Actually Love the Emperor?

The Heresy novels spend considerable effort making Horus sympathetic before his fall. Whether his love for the Emperor w

Are Warhammer Novels Actually Canon?

GW's official position is that all sources are canon and all sources can be unreliable narrators simultaneously. The com